Top Rated Mattress Toppers – Best Picks for 2019

If you’re not entirely happy with your mattress, you don’t necessarily have to replace it. That’s expensive and you might run into the same problems with your new mattress. Instead, you can decide to invest in a good mattress topper. Read on to find out what is a mattress topper and what different kinds of mattress toppers are out there. We’ve also added the top rated mattress toppers for you to choose from.

What Is A Mattress Topper?

A mattress topper is a piece of removable bedding that sits on top of a mattress. You can think of it as a smaller mattress on top of your actual mattress. If your mattress is lacking in some areas, a mattress topper can be a real life saver. With a good topper you can quite easily adjust the comfort, softness, support and luxury of your bed. Not too bad!

Some websites use the terms mattress topper and mattress pad interchangeably. But they’re actually slight different. Mattress toppers are generally thicker, while mattress pads, such as the one on the left, tend to be quite thin. While toppers are designed to compensate for the shortcomings of your mattress, the pad is mostly used for protection from liquids or allergies, and for temperature regulation. It can also add some light padding to the mattress, although that is not its main function.

Mattress Topper Materials

Finding the right mattress topper can be quite the task. One of the most important things to consider is the material. This is where things get interesting. Each material has its own pros and cons. And ultimately, it comes down to what your needs are. Here’s an overview of the different mattress topper materials and the top rated mattress toppers for each material. If you already know what material you’re looking for, feel free to skip to the right section:

Skip to memory foam top rated mattress toppers

Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

I’m sure you’ve heard of memory foam before. It’s by far the most popular material for mattress toppers. And rightfully so.

Memory foam is one type of polyurethane foam. In the simplest terms, it has some special properties that set it aside from other foams. It’s temperature sensitive and becomes more firm, or viscose, in colder temperatures. In fact, if you were to put memory foam in a fridge, it would become brick hard. In its viscose state, it is slow to recover from compression. So if you press your hand into a cool memory foam mattress topper, it will take a few moments to recover its original shape. It’s as if it remembers your handprint. Hence the name memory foam.

This material conforms to your body and gives it support. People with back or hip pain have found relief in memory foam mattress toppers thanks to this property. As have others with arthritis and fibromyalgia.

There are two main things to keep in mind if you’re interested in a memory foam mattress topper. Density and thickness.

Density

Density is measured in pounds per cubic feet. Or sometimes kilograms per cubic meter. The density of mattress toppers usually ranges from 2 to 6+ pounds per cubic feet. The higher the density, the better the topper supports your body. That’s why higher densities are better for heavier people – they offer more support. Generally speaking, 4 to 5 pounds per cubic feet is a great option for most people. It offers a nice balance of softness and support.

Thickness

Memory foam toppers don’t vary as much in thickness as they do in density. Toppers are usually 1 to 4 inches thick. If you have a firm mattress and are happy with it, choose a 1 or 2 inch topper to add just a touch of softness. 3 inch toppers are a good choice for most people. They provide good support to your neck and backbone and are softer. If you’re looking for full on support and luxury, go for a 4 inch memory foam mattress topper. It will fully adjust to your body shape and enhance the experience.

Memory Foam Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Milliard's 2" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Milliard’s 2 inch memory foam mattress topper is one of the more affordable options. The topper comes with a silky bamboo cover. You can easily remove and wash it, keeping the topper clean. It’s normal for memory foam to have a specific odor at first. But just give it a few days or weeks and it will fade away. The topper is manufactured a bit smaller than the standard mattres size. This is intentional, so don’t worry. It’s not noticeable and allows you to perfectly fit sheets on your mattress and topper.

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King

Price: From $60

Buy Milliard's 2" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

BedStory 2-3" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

BedStory offers both a 2″ and a 3″ mattress topper. It’s a great way to make a slightly firmer mattress more comfortable. The topper is infused with lavender essence – a truly great touch by BedStory. Lavender is great for sleep and it also helps eliminate other odors. A microfiber cover is also added to the topper. It’s easily removable and washable and keeps the topper in great shape. Before you buy this topper, be sure to pick the right thickness on Amazon!

Sizes: Queen, King, California King

Price: From $87

BedStory 2-3" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

UTTU 3" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

This 3″ topper by UTTU is certainly one of the top rated mattress toppers from memory foam. It has a unique 2-layer design. The top layer is a 1″ Red Respira Foam that lets the topper breathe. And the bottom layer is a 2″ UTTU Dynamic Foam, which takes care of the support and softness side. The topper is surrounded by a microfiber cover, which gives it a nice soft feel. And also makes it easy to care for the topper. Just remove and wash the cover and you’re done!

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, California King

Price: From $120

UTTU 3" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

ViscoSoft 4" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

If you’re looking for extra thickness, go with this ViscoSoft 4″ topper. It consists of 2.5″ memory foam and a 1.5″ cover that is made from fluff down alternative. The memory foam takes the shape of your body, giving it support throughout the night. And the cover adds an extra plush layer to the mix. It also includes retention bands that will keep the topper nicely on your mattress. Although the price is slightly higher, the quality and variety of sizes this topper comes in, is well worth it.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Price: From $130

ViscoSoft 4" memory foam mattress topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Latex Mattress Toppers

Latex mattress toppers tend to be a bit more expensive, but they are definitely among the top rated mattress toppers. They conform to your body in a more general way than memory foam, are durable and comfortable.

Natural vs Synthetic Latex

Natural latex mattress toppers are made from latex that is harvested from rubber trees. There are no harsh chemicals in the topper and as such, there’s minimal outgassing.

Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Synthetic latex is usually made from a certain type of plastic, called SBR – Styrene Buradiene Rubber. This material is often used as a substitute for natural rubber and is generally thought to be safe.

In case you’re wondering which one is better, the winner is definitely natural latex. It’s more eco-friendly, durable, has more springiness to it, is antimicrobal, resistant to mold and mildew, and is hypoallergenic. It’s also more expensive, but if you can afford a natural one, it’s worth it.

Firmness

You can find both soft and firm latex mattress toppers. If your mattress is is hard and you’re looking for more comfort as well as pressure relief, go for a soft latex topper. This is especially nice for side sleepers. On the other hand, if your mattress is on the softer side and you want more support, go for a firm latex topper. Back and stomach sleepers will love this.

Thickness

Similar to memory foam mattress toppers, latex toppers are usually 1-4 inches thick. If you only need a slight modification to your mattress, go with a thinner one. A 2-3” latex mattress topper is great if you have night aches, such as back pain. But if you’re really unhappy with your mattress, you can go with a 3-4” latex topper for a complete redo. Remember the golden rule – the thicker the latex topper, the more drastic the change to your mattress.

Latex Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Sleep on Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Sleep on Latex offers a wide variety of latex mattress toppers. You can get choose between 1-3” for thickness and the sizes range from twin to California king. The material is 100% natural latex – no synthetics here. There is a slight odor to the topper when you first take it out of the package. But this fades in a few days and is not unpleasant.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $79

Buy Sleep on Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Take Ten's Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

These Take Ten’s latex mattress toppers are 100% natural and organic. They’re either 2” or 3” thick and come in various degrees of firmness: soft, medium, and firm. Bear in mind that the price also goes up with the firmness. The topper comes with a free cotton zippered cover, which is also organic. This makes it easy to keep the mattress topper clean. The medium firmness topper especially is definitely one of the top rated mattress toppers out there.

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal king

Price: From $144

Buy Take Ten's Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

PlushBed's Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

PlushBeds’ all-natural latex mattress toppers come in 4 degrees of firmness: soft, medium, medium-firm, and firm. If you need more support, go with a firm or medium-firm topper. It’s especially good for keeping back pains at bay. You can get a 2” mattress topper or a 3” one in various sizes.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $219

Buy PlushBed's Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

OrganicTextiles Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

OrganicTextiles offers a 3” organic latex mattress topper. The holes in the topper allow the air to flow freely and you won’t have to worry about overheating. What we love about this product is the fact that the toppers comes with a cover, which
prevents shredding and expands its lifespan. You can even pick between a bamboo and a cotton cover. Keep in mind that the cover is non removable.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $290

Buy OrganicTextiles Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

OrganicTextilesDual Firmness Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Here’s another gem from OrganicTextiles. This top rated mattress topper has a softer and a firmer side. While most mattress toppers have one firmness, this one gives you dual firmness. The topper is 2” thick, made from organic latex and is protected by a 100% organic cotton cover. It prevents the topper from shredding and you can enjoy it for a longer time. This is definitely a winner, as it gives you the option to choose how firm a topper you want to sleep on. You can even switch it up daily if you prefer.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $190

Buy OrganicTextilesDual Firmness Latex Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Wool Mattress Toppers

Wool might not be the first material to pop into your mind when thinking of mattress toppers. But they certainly earn a spot in our top rated mattress toppers list.

Wool is a natural material and comes with a variety of benefits. It’s better for people who are looking for a softer mattress topper. Foam and latex mattresses are known for providing more support, making them a better choice for people with back and neck pains. Wool mattress toppers, on the other hand, are more suitable if you want a more cozy and comfortable feel.

One of the best things about wool is its ability to maintain the body’s natural temperature. It keeps us warm during winter, but also has a cooling effect in the summer. Not only that! It also wicks moisture, keeping you dry.

Wool is naturally flame resistant. Which is a great advantage when compared to many other materials, especially synthetic ones. Wool bedding naturally meets flammability requirements, so no chemical flame retardants are added. It also inhibits the growth of different allergens, such as mold, bacteria, and dust mites.

Because of its great qualities, wool mattress toppers can be more expensive. But if you’re looking for something natural, temperature regulating and hypoallergenic, it is surely one of the top rated mattress toppers and might just be the right choice for you.

Wool Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Sleep & Beyond Shropshire Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

This wool mattress topper from Sleep & Beyond is filled with 100% Shropshire wool and protected by a cover, made from 100% natural
percale cotton. Shropshire wool is light, elastic and fine to the touch. It’s definitely a premium choice when it comes to wool. You can also clean it less frequently than other fibers. It’s a great topper to soften a hard mattress and to regulate temperature during your sleep.

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Crib

Price: From $139

Buy Sleep & Beyond Shropshire Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Sleep & Beyond Merino Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

You have likely heard of Merino wool. It comes from the Merino sheep and is thinner and softer than your regular wool. This mattress topper by
Sleep & Beyond is made of organic Merino wool. It is protected by an organic cotton cover. The topper is 1.5” thick and adds just the right amount of padding. It’s a high quality topper and will keep the temperature just right for you.

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $279

Buy Sleep & Beyond Merino Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Bio Sleep Concept's Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Bio Sleep Concept’s mattress topper is made of wool that comes from the Blackface sheep, raised in the north west of the USA. The fibers of this sheet breed have a more stable length than many others and is considered a great filling for wool bedding. It has all the usual benefits of a wool – regulates your body temperature, keeps away dust mites as well as other allergens.

Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, 80” x 39” x 3”

Price: From $305

Buy Bio Sleep Concept's Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Holy Lamb Organics's Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers

Holy Lamb Organics has one of the top rated mattress toppers. It’s made from wool, grown in the Pacific Northwest of the USA. This is a great topper if you have allergies, or tend to sleep too hot or too cold. Wool is a great breathable material and is also moisture wicking. The wool topper is covered by a certified organic sateen cotton cover. It’s a perfect topper to soften a hard mattress and let you sleep comfortably through the night.

Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Price: From $395

Buy Holy Lamb Organics's Wool Mattress Topper - Top Rated Mattress Toppers